This D-Day Hypothetical Question Has Everybody Talking. What Would You Choose?

David Hookstead | Smoke Room Editor-in-Chief

I posed a hypothetical question on the 74th anniversary of D-Day Wednesday, and it got some very interesting reactions.

My question was a simple one: Would you rather have been on the first wave to hit Omaha Beach, or would you rather have been a paratrooper to land behind enemy lines without a weapon (which happened a lot)?

I posed this question on Twitter, and the results aren’t close. As of this moment, 80 percent of people chose the option of being a paratrooper without a gun. (SLIDESHOW: CELEBRATE THE 74TH ANNIVERSARY OF D-DAY WITH THESE EPIC PHOTOS)

Here are a few of the responses to the question below.

I spoke to somebody last night with a decent amount of knowledge of the situation, there are risks and the rewards to both options. The answer, however, is a simple one to me. You should choose to be an unarmed paratrooper without a doubt.

Here’s why I think it’s the correct option. Paratroopers were dropped at night, which gives you a certain automatic level of cover. Yes, not having a weapon would suck, but Richard Winters made it through D-Day after landing without a weapon. You could sneak around until you’re able to link back up with some American soldiers, grab a gun off of a dead soldier or get a backup weapon from an allied force.

Omaha Beach? That’s a bit of a different story. There’s nowhere to hide, and it’s light out. The men on those beaches were running directly into German fire. I would without question prefer to be an unarmed paratrooper and it’s not even close.

Fire off in the comment section which you would choose out of the two options.

Follow David on Twitter

David Hookstead

Smoke Room Editor-in-Chief
Follow David Hookstead on Twitter and Instagram


Lyna Perez Tries To Break The Internet With Insane Photo. Does It Go Too Far?
Demi Rose Shares Wild Bikini Picture On Instagram
Start Your Day With This Hailey Clauson Swimsuit Photo
Meet The Hottest Women Of The UFC